LP8-Case Law Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words

LP8-Case Law - Assignment Example However, on its part the court argued that Michael waived his right to stay silent and this was due to his request to consult his probation officer. The main issue on this case was to inquire whether by requesting that he consult his probation officer, Michael’s right under the Fifth Amendment was invoked (Fare v. Michael C. 442 U.S. 707 1979). The court held that since under the criminal justice system attorneys and probation officers are different, then Michael rights were not violated. According to Justice Blackmun, while attorney plays a significant role in the adversarial process, probation officers do not provide equally assistance in the custodial interrogation and thus speaking to the two officers cannot be treated in a similar way. Additionally, the court argued that the minor was aware that he waived his rights. This implied that there was a chance of more interrogation. In my opinion, the police could have allowed the respondent to speak to his probation officer. According to the US Supreme court, any one who exercises his or her right to remain silent should not be punished. Thus, the interrogators were supposed to allow Michael to speak to the probation officer who could then provide more information that could assist the judge and the prosecutors in the trial process. During the case, the court held that it was not a must that the warnings given by the police to the accused use same words as indicated by Miranda opinion. In this case, I support the court’s holding. The case of California v. Prysock case involves a victim who was murdered in 1978. After the killing, a minor was arrested and taken to Tulare County department where he was reminded on his Miranda rights. Despite efforts by the police to retrieve information from the respondent, he declined to talk. This made the police to notify his parents since the

Research paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 11

Research Paper Example Among the main concerns that are raised concerning the move are: what is the main motive of India launching mars orbiter especially with increased space exploration across the globe, and, is there a rivalry in competition between China and India concerning space exploration? Therefore, this discussion aims at establishing reasons why India’s space exploration is such an esteemed undertaking amidst complains on increased poverty levels and substantiate on claims that India invests in space exploration to counter China’s supremacy in space exploration within the Asian region. Discussion In a recent article by MacAskill and Nagarajan (2013), India, have plans underway to launch a space ship ‘Mars Orbiter’ towards Mars as race for space power intensifies between the country and China. The two countries are the recent entrants into the race with US, Russia as well as Europe having already launched space explorers into the mars orbit in the past. It is however wo rth noting that in spite of the open contest between India and China in space supremacy, few or none of the officials in India would not admit this. â€Å"India is clearly concerned about China’s recent rise in space prestige and wants to minimize that damage† (MacAskill and Nagarajan, 2013) as is reported by the report and this illustrates the tag existing between the Asian countries. There have been ongoing debates and research studies aimed at establishing the truth in the postulation that India’s increased zeal to launch the mars orbiter is for competition with China as a rival in Asia as against being propelled by reason of gathering scientific knowledge on existence of life on Mars or even to showcase technology advancement of the country. This study therefore identifies the problem in justifying the motives of space exploration by India and sets forth to substantiate the claim. This therefore makes the question of ‘what exactly is the aim to the gre at exploration investments?’ paramount to the discussion. Besides the main goal of this essay as being to investigate the above posed question, this study envisions to contribute towards bridging the previously identified gap in literature concerning the motives of India launch of the mars orbiter. This study will also guide in future studies in the same theme where the findings will be instrumental in revealing the direction to be taken by future researchers of Asian space exploration in the 21st century. Indian government and the space exploration mission is not based on race towards space exploration supremacy as argued by many. On the contrary, Indian mars exploration is meant to gather scientific information and displaying Indian technology in space exploration. Depending on various literatures available on the topic, there is justifiable evidence to support the postulation above. Technological development as well as social development is necessities for economic growth and development within any nation. India is seen to have increasingly invested in space exploration in the recent past, a phenomenon that sparks heated debates on the intentions while majority of the population in the country still live in absolute poverty. Among many other missions, that India continues to undertake in space exploration in the launch of mars orbiter is a major one. However, with claims circulating that India is determined